Trump's $15 Billion Lawsuit Against The New York Times Just Survived — Here's What Happens Next
Official 2025 presidential portrait of Donald Trump by Daniel Torok, released into the public domain. Via Wikimedia Commons.
A federal judge in Florida has just handed Donald Trump a major victory in his $15 billion legal battle with The New York Times — ruling that the president's defamation lawsuit against the newspaper and its publisher can move forward. The decision, issued on Thursday, November 19, keeps one of the biggest media lawsuits in American history alive.
U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday, sitting in Tampa, rejected the Times' request to throw the case out entirely. But the ruling was far from a clean win for the president. Merryday dismissed two of Trump's six claims and threw out 27 of the statements Trump had challenged as not actionable. What survived were four claims built around seven statements — and those seven are now heading toward a possible trial.
The Seven Statements That Could Cost the Times $15 Billion
Six of the surviving statements come from "Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father's Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success," the 2024 book by Times reporters Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner, published by Penguin Random House. The seventh comes from an October 2024 article by Times reporter Peter Baker. Together, they accuse Trump of serious financial wrongdoing — including tax fraud, tax evasion, money laundering and what the judge described as "planning and perpetrating complex crimes."
Merryday ruled that Trump had plausibly alleged the Times published those claims with "actual malice" — meaning its journalists either knew the statements were false or acted with reckless disregard for whether they were true. The judge said the claims rested on "incomplete, minimal information."
Surviving Is Not Winning
It is important to be clear about what this ruling does — and does not — mean. Merryday did not find that the Times defamed Trump, or that any of the reporting was false. At this stage, a judge only decides whether the allegations are strong enough to survive a motion to dismiss. The hard part for Trump still lies ahead.
Because Trump is the president — one of the most prominent public figures in the country — he must clear the highest bar in American defamation law. Under the Supreme Court's landmark 1964 decision in New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, a public official cannot win damages unless he proves the statements were false and published with actual malice — a standard very few public figures have ever met.
The Times has rejected the lawsuit as "a baseless attack on The Times and the rights of the free and independent press in this country." The newspaper will now argue its case as the lawsuit moves toward discovery, when both sides must hand over documents and give sworn testimony.
A Lawsuit That Was Almost Thrown Out on Day One
This case has already had a dramatic history. Trump filed the lawsuit in September 2025, accusing the Times, four of its journalists and Penguin Random House of false, malicious claims about his business career, his inheritance and his role in creating "The Apprentice" — claims he said were meant to damage him before the 2024 election, which he won.
Within days, Judge Merryday threw out the original 85-page complaint, calling it "florid and enervating" and "improper and impermissible in its present form." He noted the filing did not formally allege defamation until page 80, and gave Trump's lawyers 28 days to refile a shorter version — limited to 40 pages. They did, and the case has been fought over the revised complaint ever since.
What Happens Next
The Times and Penguin Random House now have 28 days to respond to the surviving claims, and the case moves toward discovery and a possible trial. The judge also refused Trump's request to amend his complaint again. The case is Trump v. New York Times Co., in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida.
Whatever happens next, the ruling is a warning shot for the American press. Trump has made lawsuits against news organisations a central part of his second presidency, and this decision shows at least one federal judge believes his claims deserve to be heard. For the Times, the fight — and the $15 billion question — is only just beginning.
Source: Reuters, November 19, 2026; TheWrap; Law Commentary.
