A Second Judge Just Blocked Trump's 250-Foot Arch — and Called It a "Rushed Job"
Photo: The Lincoln Memorial, near the proposed arch site at Memorial Circle. Credit: NPS / Victoria Stauffenberg (public domain).
A second federal judge has now blocked President Donald Trump's plan to build a 250-foot triumphal arch in Washington — and this time, the order has no end date.
On Friday, November 20, 2026, U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema of the Eastern District of Virginia said from the bench that she would grant Arlington County's request for a preliminary injunction, halting construction of the arch indefinitely while the legal challenge continues. It is the second time in a single week that a federal court has stopped the project.
Brinkema did not hold back. She called the project a "rushed job" and told government lawyers that relying on the statute they cited to justify it "hurts your credibility with the court."
Two judges, one week, the same verdict
Brinkema is the second judge to rule against the arch this week. On Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington, D.C., extended a temporary restraining order that prevents the Trump administration from breaking ground through December 3 while she considers the underlying legal arguments. Chutkan first blocked construction on November 5, shortly after the National Capital Planning Commission gave the arch its final approval in an 8–4 vote, despite dozens of witnesses who spoke against it.
The difference now is duration. Chutkan's order expires on December 3. Brinkema's injunction has no specified expiration date — it stays in place for as long as the case is being heard.
Why the judges say the arch cannot go ahead
The arch would stand at Memorial Circle, on the Virginia side of the Potomac River, between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery — a short distance from Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport.
Brinkema found multiple defects in the government's case. She said the administration's analysis of the project's economic and environmental impact was inadequate, including its failure to properly explain how the arch would affect the nearby airport. She also pointed to a lack of authorization from Congress — a central argument in the lawsuits against the project.
The case before Brinkema was brought by the County Board of Arlington, Virginia, which sued in October. A separate challenge in Washington was filed by the attorneys general of Washington, D.C., and Virginia, along with a group of Vietnam War veterans.
The White House is fighting back
The Justice Department says it is not backing down. Department spokesperson Matthew Nies told NPR that the government "will appeal the district court's decision immediately."
The arch is the centrepiece of Trump's campaign to reshape Washington's historic buildings and spaces in his image. He has described a monument taller than the Lincoln Memorial, built to celebrate 250 years of American independence. Critics have called it a vanity project; supporters have called it a fitting tribute.
For now, though, the courts have the final word — and two judges in two different courts have reached the same conclusion: the administration rushed the project through without the legal groundwork to support it.
What happens next
The administration's appeal will go to a higher court, but appeals take time, and the injunction means no construction can begin in the meantime. Meanwhile, Chutkan's separate order in Washington runs until December 3, when she will decide whether to impose a longer-term block of her own.
If both injunctions hold, the arch — one of the most controversial building projects in modern Washington — may never break ground at all. And if the administration wins on appeal, it will still have to answer the same questions about Congress, the environment, and the airport that two judges have now said it failed to answer the first time.
Either way, the monument Trump wanted rising over the capital by America's 250th birthday is now stuck in court — indefinitely.
Source: NPR, Associated Press, Bloomberg Law, CNN (November 20, 2026). Photo: NPS / Victoria Stauffenberg (public domain).
